The Crossings at Siesta Key: A Major Transformation for South Sarasota Real Estate The gateway to Siesta Key is set for a dramatic makeover. Benderson Development is moving forward with the ambitious transformation of the former Southgate Mall property, now known as The Crossings at Siesta Key, into a vibrant, mixed-use lifestyle village. This project, located at 3501 S. Tamiami Trail, represents one of the most significant commercial and residential initiatives in South Sarasota’s recent history.The Vision: A Walkable, Mixed-Use Town Center Following the Sarasota City Commission’s approval of a Comprehensive Plan amendment in October 2024, the vision for this 34-to-35-acre site has become clear: to create a modern, urbanist-style town center. Instead of a traditional mall, the property will be converted into a lively, walkable community featuring a gridded block of streets and high levels of pedestrian and bicycle connectivity. The goal is to establish a dynamic destination comparable to successful concepts like Naples’ Mercado. Components of the New Center: The project’s residential component is crucial to its mixed-use strategy and holds significant implications for local housing: This redevelopment is a major, long-term investment. Due to the necessary scope, which includes the demolition of the main mall building, substantial stormwater mitigation, and respecting existing long-term tenant leases, the full build-out is a phased process. Benderson Development anticipates the project will take 10 to 15 years to complete. For local homeowners and potential buyers, this transformation is a positive sign for the South Gate community. The creation of a dense, high-quality, and walkable town center right on the South Tamiami Trail corridor is expected to elevate the area’s overall appeal, boost commercial activity, and reinforce the long-term value of nearby residential properties.
- Retail and Dining: New retail spaces and restaurants will be introduced, complementing existing, long-standing tenants like Cinebistro and Connors Steak & Seafood, which are slated to remain.
- Residential: The eastern side of the property is planned for a major residential component.
- Commercial: The plan also includes dedicated office space and a hotel.
- Residential Density: Plans allow for the construction of up to 848 apartment units.
- Attainable Housing: In a notable commitment to the community, Benderson has proffered that 10% of the residential units—up to 85 units—will be designated as attainable housing. These units will be priced affordably for residents earning up to 120% of the area median income (AMI).
Why the Crossings at Siesta Key Redevelopment Matters to Homeowners The redevelopment of the old Southgate Mall into "The Crossings at Siesta Key" mixed-use center by Benderson Development represents one of the most important real estate and community initiatives in South Sarasota. Here’s why this development at 3501 S. Tamiami Trail is key for local real estate:
- A Focus on Density and Housing: The approved plan allows for a substantial residential component—up to 848 apartment units. This increase in density near a major commercial corridor is a vital element of modern urban planning for the region.
- Commitment to Attainability: A notable aspect of the approval is Benderson’s commitment to designate 10% of the residential units as attainable housing. This means up to 85 units will be priced affordably for residents earning up to 120% of the area median income.
- Boosting Local Appeal: By creating a dense, walkable, town-center environment with a curated mix of retail, restaurants, and offices, the development is expected to elevate the quality of life and commercial activity in the South Tamiami Trail corridor. This kind of significant commercial and residential reinvestment near key neighborhoods like South Gate has a positive long-term effect on property values and market interest.
- Long-View Strategy: Benderson Development has indicated they plan to own this property forever, signifying a commitment to a phased, decade-long build-out (10 to 15 years) that will ensure a high-quality, successful, mixed-use center.
Check out this article next
